Articles
Advice of the Day (Forum)
Books (Forum)
Druidic Ramblings (Forum)
Dumb Ideas (Forum)
H-Town (Forum)
Links (Forum)
Movies (Forum)
Music (Forum)
Opinions (Forum)
Photo Albums (Forum)
Prose/Poetry (Forum)
Questions (Forum)
Video Games (Forum)
Member Login

Username

Password

Register Here

Forum
 

Forum posts for New Wolfshack Features?

Hm.
Posted by phduffy on Nov 20, 2006
To your last point...

Isn't that what the forums does already? If you want to see recent forum content, just click on the forums link. The good thing about the way the home page is set up now is that sometimes there's good stuff that gets no comments. You could quickly lose that if there were a bunch of forum topics going wild.

Yes
Posted by Nerhael on Nov 20, 2006
That is what the forums link does now, but to be honest, I stopped clicking there a long time ago, typically because most of the posting was on recent posts themselves.

I think the layout of the homepage would be updated to allow for more content to show up, and new posts vs new articles would both get flagged. I'd just prefer one page where everything 'new' showed up basically. I would also say that we are seldom seeing lots of posts across multiple topics that would really push down a new topic that fast.

Also, I know I've managed to completely miss new posts now and then because they don't have that "NEW* thing beside them.

.
Posted by phduffy on Nov 20, 2006
Hm, so maybe two 'new' flags? One for the articles and one for forum posts?

I'm surprised that you don't click on the forums link though. Isn't that a flaw* of yourself, rather than the web design here?

*flaw here should be taken incredibly lightly

Personally
Posted by Nerhael on Nov 20, 2006
I'd call that a design flaw. You always want to minimize user effort/clicks to get at information.

Ultimately, the information on the homepage should present all *new* content, regardless of whether it's a flat out new topic, or an existing topic with a new response to it.

I would say that any site design that allows a user to easily not see new content/use the site's function, (like this), is more a flaw of the system than the user.

I stopped checking it cause typically it showed me something new. That became habit, hence when it did have something new, I would miss it. A personal flaw I feel was generated by the nature of our site.

either http, https, or..
Posted by crux on Nov 21, 2006
This wasn't on your list, but I think I've mentioned it to you before. I'd like to have the ability to comment on specific replies within a post; so kind of a multi-tier response structure. Especially when there's a particularly lengthy discussion going on it can be confusing to figure out which previous post someone is responding to. Some would say the confusion only ads to the discussion (and maybe they're right), but this is my suggestion. Now if you did this we would probably need to tag individual replies as 'New' since just scrolling to the bottom won't necessarily show you all of the latest posts.

If you need help testing any new features I might have considerably more free time on my hands soon. My company is hemorrhaging money so bad right now I'm frequently tempted to shout out "MEDIC!!" while reviewing our expense and revenue reports.

Yikes
Posted by phduffy on Nov 21, 2006
I would like to strongly voice my disagreement with crux's idea of tiered-responses.

This assumes that your idea would create forums that look anything like POE's forums. POE's forums are the worst I have ever seen, and I honestly don't think I'd follow discussion here if it was like that. If I'm understanding this incorrectly, please explain it to me.

Also, I liked the new look, the white on black. It reminds me of the BestPage in the Universe, and anything that reminds me of that can't be bad.

In terms of showing new links and new forum posts, you could check out here:
http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/files/newsstand/

Now, there's too much going on there, but the basics are: the middle of the page shows all the new content. On the right, you see the most recent forum activity, as well as the most recent poster. And you can bookmark threads so that you'll instantly be able to see if anyone's commented on them.

it loads your post
Posted by crux on Nov 21, 2006
No, not like POE's forums. I dislike the way they're structured as well. There's too much clicking involved in trying to follow a thread. I'm thinking more like LiveJournal style. How can I explain it? Like all the replies would still be openly visible on the page. I'm just talking about organizing them in a different way. So if you wanted to reply to something someone said in the 3rd post of a thread with 15 posts, rather than your post appearing at the bottom as the 16th post it would be displayed under the 3rd post slightly indented to indicate that it's a reply to that specific post. Does that make ANY sense at all?

.
Posted by phduffy on Nov 21, 2006
Ah, okay. I think that makes sense. So your post would be indented a little or something? Or... Hm, so each reply to the original article shows up normally. Then, if you reply to one of those replies, you get indented. Repeat as desired?

Do you have a link to a live journal entry that works like this?

asdfasf
Posted by crux on Nov 21, 2006
Something like this:

http://community.livejournal.com/_scientists_/807435.html

urp
Posted by Thrillhouse on Nov 24, 2006
I don't think this has been mentioned, but what about being able to see the forum posts right after the main article instead of having to click the "X Forum Posts" link at the end? Yes? No? Maybe?

Yeah
Posted by Nerhael on Nov 24, 2006
I agree on that one. Also a bad design choice.

I can just as easily style the two body's of content to keep them seperated as keep them on completely separate pages.

?
Posted by cosmicfish on Nov 25, 2006
could we edit our profile info to update email addresses and the like?

My vote
Posted by Miguel on Nov 27, 2006
I for one think that the wolfshack could use a little more pornography. Tasteful of course. Im thinking Russian ladies or perhaps something involving a tea party.

race doesn't matter...
Posted by bryan on Nov 28, 2006
...as long as they are pouring borscht all over each other.

yum.

Posted by Nerhael on Nov 28, 2006
Posts no longer bitch at you for not having a title.